Baking Cookies with the Daring Bakers

The July Daring Bakers’ challenge was hosted by Nicole at Sweet Tooth. She chose Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Cookies and Milan Cookies from pastry chef Gale Gand of the Food Network.

I was excited this month when I saw that the Daring Bakers would be making cookies. I can trace my interest in cooking and baking back to baking cookies with my family, particularly my mom, for the holidays. To this day, I still love to bake cookies with friends and family.  So, I am always excited to discover a new cookie recipe (or in this case, two).

The challenge gave the option to make one or both of the recipes – I opted to make both.  In addition to my pictures and comments on the cookies, I have provided the links to the original recipes below.

Mallows (Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Cookies)
Recipe courtesy Gale Gand, from Food Network site

The mallows were a bit labor intensive, but I had an enjoyable time making them. I was especially excited to make them because the recipe included making homemade marshmallows, something I have wanted to do for a while. It was also the first time I have played with my new digital candy thermometer from Williams-Sonoma!

I’m not sure if I will make this exact recipe again – I wasn’t thrilled with the taste of the cookie base.  I am sure that the concept will inspire a few of my own creations, though.  I am looking forward to making some homemade marshmallows again sometime soon!

First, mix the cookie dough.  Form a disk and wrap with plastic wrap.  Chill for at least one hour.

Then, roll out the dough and cut into circles using a 1 1/2 inch cookie cutter (or in my case, the back of a pastry tip).  The recipe made a few more than 2 dozen cookies (about 10-11 dozen, actually).  I’m not sure if I did something wrong, but they tasted fine!

Once the cookies have cooled, prepare the marshmallows.  Start by mixing corn syrup, sugar, and water in a sauce pan and cooking to soft ball stage. Dissolve gelatin into the syrup and add to whipped egg whites.  Beat until stiff.

Pipe the marshmallow mixture onto the cooled cookies.  Coat with chocolate (I used 60% Cacao Bittersweet Chips from Ghiradelli – one of my favorites).

Milan Cookies
Recipe courtesy Gale Gand, from Food Network site

The Milan Cookies are based on one of my favorite store bought cookies.  I must say, though, that I think I prefer the store bought version to this recipe. I found the lemon extract in the recipe to be just a bit overpowering in the cookies.  Next time I make them, I think I will use slightly less extract.

Overall, the cookies were pretty easy to make. I found that the cookies turned out better made a bit larger than the recipe called for, though.  Instead of using a 1/4 inch tip and piping one inch of batter for each cookie, I used a 1/2 inch round tip and piped closer to 2-3 inch lines onto the baking sheet.  The cookies turned out to be approximately the same size as the store bought cookies.  I did bake them for an extra minute or so to make sure they were done.

Prepare the batter in a mixer, then pipe the cookies onto a parchment paper lined cookie sheet.

To prepare the filling, first scald the heavy cream.  Add to the chocolate (again, I used 60% Cacao Bittersweet Chips from Ghiradelli) and zest from one orange. Spread the mixture onto the flat side of one cookie, topping with a second cookie to form a sandwich.

36 Responses to Baking Cookies with the Daring Bakers

  1. They both “Look” great… it’s too bad the recipes didn’t hit the ball out of the park for you. They look better than the store version visually!

  2. Teanna says:

    I am SO impressed! CAn I just tell you, I was craving Mallows so badly the other day, and I don’t even like them! But these… wow… these… I absolutely have to make these! Both version! so, so impressed! But I am sorry that you didn’t like them so much!

  3. isa says:

    They both looks and sounds delicious!
    Love your step-by-step photos!
    I’m so sorry, that you didn’t love them.
    Nicely done!

  4. Julie Ruble says:

    Your cookies look fantastic! Your mallows especially — I love their shape!!

  5. Lisa says:

    WOW, your Mallows are perfect little kisses, and the chocolate set up perfectly. Love them presented in the little paper liners. As for the Milanos, I would swear those were by Pep Farm! Amazing job!

  6. Great job with these cookies! Sorry to hear that you didn’t like the mallows so much; Milanos sound delicious.

  7. Anula says:

    I love the shape of your mallows! Your Milano cookies look very delicious :)

  8. Tracy says:

    Yours came out great! Lovely!!

  9. Hannah says:

    Incredible, both of your cookies look flawless! I really like the star tip you used to pipe the marshmallows with- it’s such a cute finishing touch.

  10. Nutmeg Nanny says:

    Your Daring Bakers Challenge looks so good! I only did one recipe for the challenge because I ran out of time to do both…darn thesis. I’m going to post my DB challenge later tonight since I had to post the BSI challenge this morning….two post in one day! I’m so glad you are going to participate in the BSI challenge this week, I can’t wait to see what you make!!!

  11. jenn says:

    Awesome job, Jen!!! I love how the Milan cookies came out. They’re one of mt favs!! I wish I had some right now. You don’t shipping some over, do ya? ;-)

  12. Kayte says:

    Wow, you make beautiful cookies! I am not fond of chocolate, so I won’t lie and say these look mouth wataeringly great, but I know my family would think so as they love chocolate. The cookies are great looking and the little marshmallow ones so cute. I love how you display them. You are one very organized and neat baker! Great photos.

  13. I am so impressed seeing the very full tray of mallows whilst in production. I don’t think I would have the patience to make so many. They both look wonderful!

  14. Your mellows and milanos look stunning!!

  15. April says:

    Don’t you just love homemade marshmallows? And I also agree about the lemon being a bit too strong in these cookies but they were pretty tasty just on their own, without the chocolate. Both of your desserts look great!

  16. These cookies look scrumptious.

  17. Jill says:

    I love how your Mallows turned out–so cute by being piped with a star tip. Great pics! :)

  18. Ivonne says:

    Your cookies are absolutely beautiful, especially the mallows! Well done!

  19. Debi says:

    Very nice job with your photos in this post. Looks like you stepped up to the plate and bat a home one on this baker’s challenge.

  20. SunDrawnSarah says:

    Gorgeous photos! I’ll be checking back for more!

  21. Nutmeg Nanny says:

    I love that you made both! So adventurous you are:) Your creations (like always) look beautiful.

  22. chou says:

    Your pictures are like a personal tutorial. Lovely piping.

  23. jillian says:

    Nice job on making both cookies!

  24. Elizabeth F. says:

    Your mallows are absolutely perfect!

  25. Laura says:

    I love that you piped the marshmallow with a star tip, they look adorable. Fantastic job!

  26. bergamot says:

    wow… both the cookies and the mallows look just yummy…perfect

  27. deeba says:

    Picture of perfection. Love the detailed photographs too. I got the numbers going a ‘bit’ way out too!! LOL…2 dozen??? II got about 8-9 dozen mallow bases. I tried just the Mallows, & LOVED them!!

  28. […] homemade marshmallow to the store-bought. However, in spite of the fact that several other Daring Bakers had no problem setting up their chocolate, mine won’t stay solid outside of the fridge. […]

  29. Kathlyn says:

    These are lovely – and the photos are fantastic! I’m glad you included a photo of your Milan batter – did not look a thing like mine, which leads me to believe that I did indeed make a serious error…and also makes me think it’s worth trying again…


  30. Reeni says:

    They both turned out perfect!! They look so scrumptious and delicious!

  31. Lauren says:

    Wow! Gorgeous job =D. All of your cookies are stunning, and your photos are beautiful!!

  32. Jamie says:

    Gorgeous, love the mallows! I really enjoyed this challenge!

  33. Christina says:

    Love all of the photos! Great looking cookies!

  34. kalva says:

    lovely milanos!!!

  35. Michelle says:

    Such lovely cookies! Beautiful photos, too!

  36. […] Our Way Challenge was to make soft pretzels.  As with many of the other challenges this month (Daring Bakers, not to mention any names), I waited until the last minute to make these pretzels.  It […]

Leave a reply